Debating Stimulus payouts vs. Tax cuts

Okay then. Our first debate.

Which is better? Stimulus payout? Or Tax cuts (to promote business.)
I think that Tax cuts are better because they promote growth. I made a bullet'd list of what could happen:

• Neshubakastan issues a 10% Tax cut on earnings from 20%  of total last year.
• Nijan inc. makes $1,000,000 in profit this year.
• Nijan then has $900,000 left after tax.
• Nijan buys $400,000 in supplies, where as last year they bought only $250,000.
• Nijan then makes $1,200,000 the next year.
• Nijan gives out bonuses for the great year to every employee, who all buy a 3D-TV.
• Pascaano inc. makes 3D-TVs.
• Pascaano makes $250,000 from Nijan's employees.
• Pascaano's stock goes up 18%.

Now, lets give some people bailouts.

• Bunta-ko inc. is $50,000,000 in debt.
• Asona's Government gives Bunta-ko $75,000,000.
• Bunta-ko is similar to Kouma, who also had the same debt and got the same amount of money from Asona.
• Bunta-ko has $25,000,000 left, so buys out rival Atamesho.
• Bunta-ko's stock goes up 10%.
• Meanwhile, Kouma has also $25,000,000 extra.
• Kouma has had a record year despite debt (all of which was from a lawsuit against Kom-Toijok.)
• Kouma pays its top 5 CEOs $5,000,000 EACH.
• All CEOs put their new dough in a Swiss bank, never to be seen again.

Whaddya think?